This no-fail pan-seared stove top steak recipe teaches you how to make a gourmet comfort food dinner that rivals what you get at a fancy steak house! An easy method with no fancy ingredients necessary to serve steak with perfectly seared edges and tender, juicy meat inside at any temperature doneness you desire. Topped with a steak house butter for deliciousness in each bite.
Nothing beats a great steak dinner in my book. Being from the midwest I’m a true believer in having a great steak as often as you can. Going out for dinner can get expensive though. I’m here today to share a pan-seared stove top steak recipe that tastes just like you are at a fancy steakhouse!
A gourmet comfort food meal that not only is cooked to perfection (tender, juicy and flavorful,) it’s also slathered in a homemade steakhouse butter that will make you want to get every last drop up of before finishing eating. Oh, did I mention how much cheaper to make this steakhouse dinner at home is to make? A complete win!
If you’ve been following me for a while you know I love a good grilled steak like this bourbon garlic buttered grilled ribeye. But sometimes the weather doesn’t allow for grilling outside. When that happens I use a tried and true method of pan searing a steak on the stove top.
Cooking steak need not be stressful when making it for company. Today I’m going to share all of the things you’ll need to know to make a gourmet steakhouse dinner with complete confidence. At the end of this post you will know how to:
- Buy the best steak for cooking in a pan
- Know what kind of pan to use to cook steak on the stovetop
- What temperature to cook a steak to
- Tips to guarantee a great steak dinner
What kinds of steaks work best cooked in a pan?
- Rib Eye
- New York Strip
Quality cuts of beef like the tenderloin/filet, a ribeye or a New York strip, sirloins are ideal cuts to cook in a pan. They can be cooked quickly at high heats and still be tender.
Cuts like briskets, roasts and London broils are not suited to this method as they need a longer time cooking to break down the fibers to achieve a tender piece of meat.
What type of pan to cook steak in and why?
Once you’ve gotten the steak home you’ll want to cook the steak on the stove top in the right pan. What kind of pan do I recommend for this steak dinner? I recommend a cast iron skillet to pan-sear a steak. They conduct heat really well. They are usually heavy and heat very evenly which means that your steak will cook the same everywhere.
Like this? Pin it!
How do you cook stovetop steak?
- Season steaks generously with salt and pepper
- Heat the cast iron pan to extremely hot to get a good sear
- Leave the steak alone- only flip it once to get a perfect seared crust
- Place a butter disc on the steak once you flip the steak
- Once steak is at the desired doneness, remove from the skillet and allow it to rest
- Serve the steak with an additional pat of Bercy butter on top
What temperature to cook steaks to:
Use a thermometer to check the temperature for perfect doneness every time.
- Rare 125°
- Medium 135°-140°
- Medium Well 140° – 150°
Tips and Questions you may have when making a steakhouse dinner at home:
- Buy quality meat and look for cuts that are the same thickness in the whole steak. This makes it easier to get the steak done the same throughout. No rare in one area and medium in another if the steak is all the same thickness.
- Always bring the steak to room temperature before cooking it. A cold steak not only takes longer to cook, but it can also cook very unevenly.
- Season the steak generously. Salt brings out the flavor of the steak and also helps give the steak a great crust.
- Can you freeze the leftovers? Pan-seared steak is much better if it is eaten right away and I don’t recommend freezing it.
- How to warm up leftover steak? I suggest heating the steak in a pan on low, paying careful to not let the meat get to dried out. Add additional butter when cooking to keep the steak nice and juicy.
- How long does a cooked pan-seared steak last? Stove top steak will keep in the fridge for 1-2 days.
- What if I don’t own a cast iron skillet? Not to worry if you dont own a cast iron skillet for cooking the steak. Use a heavy bottom pan, like copper core or any solid pan that is not coated for non stick. Using non-stick pans for a stovetop steak donuts let a good crust form in them so I do not recommend using one for cooking steak.
More Steak recipes you might enjoy:
What to serve with pan-seared steaks?
- Twice Baked Potatoes (pictured, recipe coming soon)
- Crispy Roasted Greek Potatoes
- Easy Creamy Scalloped Potatoes
- Cheesy Broiled Endive
- Grilled Asparagus (lemon garlic butter)
- Buttered Mushrooms
STAY CONNECTED ON SOCIAL SO YOU DON’T MISS OUT ON THE LATEST RECIPES TO MAKE ENTERTAINING BOTH STRESS FREE AND DELICIOUS!
FREE TIPS FOR ENTERTAINING WITH EASE AND FUN DELICIOUS RECIPES WHEN YOU SIGN UP FOR THE MAILING LIST BELOW THE RECIPE !
This no fail pan-seared stove top steak recipe teaches you how to make a gourmet comfort food dinner that rivals what you get at a fancy steak house! Easy method with no fancy ingredients necessary to serve steak with perfectly seared edges and tender, juicy meat inside at any temperature doneness you desire. Topped with a steak house butter for deliciousness in each bite.
- 4 8 ounce Tenderloin steaks 1 1/4" thick steaks
- 8 ounces Bercy Butter, cut to 8 small coin slices. steakhouse butter
- salt and pepper to taste
30 minutes before cooking, remove steak from fridge and allow to come to room temp.
Heat a cast iron skillet to high.... allow it to get very hot, about 10 minutes. While skillet is getting hot, use a paper towel to pat the steak dry then season both sides of steaks generously with salt and pepper.
Place steaks into pan allowing 2" between each steak. If you have a smaller skillet, cook in batches. You should hear sizzling when you ad the steaks to pan. Do not move the steak until its time to flip it to allow a good solid crust to form.
Use a thermometer to cook to desired doneness. If using the thermometer to determine doneness, cook to 125° for rare 135-140° for Medium 140-150° for medium well. (See notes for time estimations) Flip at half way through. When you flip the steak place one small pat of Bercy butter on top to allow it to melt while it finishes cooking.
Do Not move the steak until it is time to remove it from the skillet.
Once steak is to desired doneness, remove to a side plate to rest.
Allow steak to rest for 10 minutes before serving. Serve with one additional pat of Bercy butter on top of the steak when done resting.
Steak cooking time estimates for 1- 1/4" steak.
Rare -6-7 minutes total
Medium Rare 8-9 minutes total
Medium 10-11 minutes total
Medium Well 12-13 minutes total