These creepy eyeball meatballs are a festive Halloween food idea that you can do in no time. Juicy, tender meatballs dressed up for your Halloween party! Filling, delicious and a scary fright for your guests to nibble on!
One last easy Halloween themed food idea for your party this year! Creepy Eyeball meatballs that look a little bloodshot may look festive and spooky but each bite is made with a delicious, juicy, cheesy meatball. Can delicious bite-sized meatballs be any more fun?
It’s kind of funny how many meatball recipes are on my website, the last time I looked I think there over a dozen of them. Check out this round-up for all the Party Meatballs you would ever need for entertaining! You name it they are on this list… subs, traditional flavors, exotic flavors, beef, chicken, turkey or pork… all of them!
Until a few years ago I detested meatballs. I had a terrible phobia about wet bread in my meatballs.
I know, it’s an odd thing to be creeped out by?!?
Then my sister-in-law made these amazing meatballs that had no bread in them, but instead had potatoes in them. I sat there watching her make what at the time I thought was thousands of them telling her no thank you I hate meatballs and don’t want any of them.
Then I had one. Seriously, they are to this day one of my very favorite meatballs to eat.
When she makes them at the holidays she makes a HUGE batch and they take a lot of time to make but they are simply incredible.
What makes a good meatball?
- Good, fresh ingredients.
- Making them with a light hand so they are tender.
- Adding a binder that keeps them together and keeps them nice and juicy.
- You can make them quickly.
- Allowing the formed meatballs to chill so they hold their shape after baking.
- It’s not required for a great meatball, but I really like adding cheese. It adds an extra flavor boost to a great meatball recipe.
- Making the meatballs an even shape so when you bake them (or fry them) they all cook them evenly.
Need More Ideas for Halloween Food Ideas? We have lots of fun ideas! Check them all out here!
How to make Halloween Theme Eyeball Meatballs:
Use your favorite meatball recipe or use the recipe I’ve included here. Then its a matter of simple additions of adding the centers of the eyes and all the bloodshot veins.
To make the eyes successfully:
You want to cut the tip-off of the olive. I used green olives and like the effect of the stuffed pimentos in the middle but you could use an olive stuffed with garlic or not stuffed at all. Of course, black olives will work too.
You want to cut the end that the pit came from. The open end. It will work the other way, but I find if you have the pointed end of the meatball still present it sticks in the meatball and tends to stay and doesn’t fall off during baking.
After you have cut the tip-off, when the time comes gently press the pointy end into the meatball.
Making the Bloodshot Eyes:
You don’t need any special tools for piping, use a zip lock or plastic bag to be able to pipe the ketchup in.
Put the ketchup in one corner of the bottom of the bag and press all of the air out and seal. Cut a small hole in the end where the ketchup is … then pipe bloodshot eyes around the eye center of the meatball.
That’s all there is to make them! Didn’t I tell you they were easy!
PIN THIS TO YOUR HALLOWEEN BOARD ON PINTEREST SO ITS EASY TO FIND WHEN YOU NEED IT!
More Halloween Food Ideas and Entertaining Tips:
- Spooky 7 layer Dip ~~. 10 different decorating ideas!! (there are also tips here for having a successful party!)
- Chocolate Halloween Dipped Cones
- Halloween Prosecco Grapes
- Halloween Pumpkin Spice Snack Mix
- Vampire Blood Cocktail (Purple Tears) I just renamed a red drink for the occasion!!
- Flying Monkeys Witches Cocktail
- Mummy Cheese Bread
- Hocus Pocus Halloween Cocktail
STAY CONNECTED ON SOCIAL SO YOU DON’T MISS OUT ON THE LATEST RECIPES TO MAKE ENTERTAINING BOTH STRESS FREE AND DELICIOUS!
FREE TIPS FOR ENTERTAINING WITH EASE AND FUN DELICIOUS RECIPES WHEN YOU SIGN UP FOR THE MAILING LIST BELOW
- Preheat oven to 350*
- Using a wooden spoon or your hands in a large bowl mix together beef, heavy cream, beaten egg, salt, oregano and panko bread crumbs.
- Do not pack the meat too tightly, you want to use a lighter touch so that the meatball does not get too compacted allowing for a lighter moist (versus heavy, hard) final product meatball.
- Once combined, sprinkle gouda cheese cubes over the top and mix to blend throughout the mixture.
- Form the meat into balls about the size of a golf ball.
- Cut the tops off of your olives. (See notes.) Press the olive point into the meatball to resemble eyes and place on a plate that will fit into the fridge for chilling. Repeat until all have "eyes"
- Chill for a minimum of 15 minutes to set the shape.
- If you are making ahead to use the next day or later in the day, you can make the meatballs to here. The meatballs in the raw state will need to be covered with plastic or foil if you are waiting longer than an hour to bake them.
WHEN YOU ARE READY TO DO THE BAKING:
- Place Meatballs onto a broiling pan (alternatively use a cookie rack over the top of a baking sheet.) You want the meatball fats to be able to fall to the bottom pan.
- The meatballs should be spaced 2" apart.
- Bake for 15-20 minutes, turning the pan from front to back at the 10 minute mark to allow for even cooking.
- Allow meatballs to cool for 5-10 mins.
- While meatballs are cooling place ketchup in a sealed zip lock back. Put the ketchup in one corner of the bottom of the bag and press all of the air out and seal. Cut a small hole in the end where the ketchup is ... then pipe bloodshot eyes around the eye center of the meatball. Serve.
As an Amazon Associate and member of other affiliate programs, I earn from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Serving Size:24 eyeballs
Amount Per Serving: Calories: 114Saturated Fat: 3gCholesterol: 36mgSodium: 305mgCarbohydrates: 2gProtein: 7g